While some personal auto insurance policies will cover you up to your policy limits for bodily injury and property damage you cause while driving a rental vehicle, others will not. Also, even if your liability coverage extemds to a rental vehicle, you may be held personally liable for any damage you cause to the rental vehicle if you don't carry comprehensive and collision coverage.
Q: Isn’t my insurance company required to cover a rental car no matter what?
A: No. While some states require insurance companies to cover rentals regardless of the circumstances, coverage in Ohio is purely a matter of contract between the insurance company and its customer, and insurance policy terms will vary. If you have questions about your policy's coverage, consult with your insurance company or an attorney before assuming you will be covered.
Q: If my insurance company doesn’t cover me when I drive a rental car, might I still be covered for a loaner car to drive while my own car is being repaired?
A: Maybe. Some individual policies that don’t cover rental vehicles still will give you limited coverage for a “temporary replacement vehicle” to be used while your own car is being serviced. Not all policies offer such coverage, and there may be restrictions that may include a time limit on the use of the loaner vehicle. Verify that your own policy has liability coverage for claims of third parties as well as comprehensive and collision coverage for damage to the loaner vehicle.
The dealership or body shop providing the loaner car may have a policy that provides customers with liability coverage and even comprehensive and collision coverage for damage to the loaner vehicle. The insurance carrier for such a policy may, however, “subrogate” or seek payment from you or your insurance carrier if the loaner car is damaged.
Q: Won’t the rental company’s insurance cover me?
A: Rental companies in all states, including Ohio, must show proof of “financial responsibility” (usually insurance or a bond) on the vehicles they rent to consumers. When you rent a car, however, most companies require you to agree to shift coverage to your personal carrier, and they often take the position that your personal insurance company is primary. Your own policy may pay before the rental company's insurance or it may state that your policy is excess to the rental company's policy. Even if the rental company’s insurance does apply, it might provide only minimum financial responsibility limits. If neither your personal auto policy nor the rental company’s insurance will pay, you can be held personally liable for any damage you cause to people and property. If your personal policy will not cover you in a rental vehicle, then consider buying supplemental coverage from the rental company for the time you have the rental vehicle.
Q: What if I don’t own a car and don’t have car insurance at all?
A: In Ohio it is against the law to drive without insurance. If you don’t have a non-owner’s policy of insurance, you may be able to buy a supplemental liability policy from a rental company that is also authorized to sell insurance.
This "Law You Can Use" consumer legal information column was provided by the Ohio State Bar Association. It was originally prepared by attorney Deborah Zaccaro, and updated by Linda Ruse, an attorney with Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company.